News RSS Feed


Sentamu views gain support

10:32am Saturday 9th December 2006

comment Comments (7)   Have your say »


THE Archbishop of York won strong support today from senior churchmen after calling for Christmas to be saved from anti-religious extremists.

Dr John Sentamu spoke out in the wake of reports that Christmas celebrations were being banned from the workplace, nativity plays were being performed without Jesus and playgroups were staging "winter festival" parties from which Christmas had been removed.

He claimed there was a worrying trend for illiberal atheists to combine with "aggressive secularists" to create a ludicrous situation, in which those who did not believe in God had decided that a Christian festival offended other faiths.

He said they were trying to pretend it was possible to enter into the true meaning of Christmas by leaving out Jesus Christ.

"The person who is at the heart of the celebration is totally excluded. This really is a case of throwing out the baby with the bathwater, or in this case throwing out the crib at Christmas."

He said such people were behaving like the inn keeper on the first Christmas Eve and saying there was no room at the inn.

"It is like having a birthday party, the guests turning up and giving each other presents, forgetting why they came and totally excluding the birthday child. Have you ever known such self-adulation and hypocrisy?" He claimed such people were trying to undermine the country's cultural traditions by using flawed arguments about "multi-faith, multi-culturalism" whilst at the same time trying to negate faith groups all together.

The Archdeacon of York, the Venerable Richard Seed, today praised Dr Sentamu's intervention as "wonderful".

He said: "I am really grateful to the Archbishop, who has completely hit the nail on the head.

"He has this great ability to challenge what the country is doing, and what individual people are doing."

The Archdeacon said there was a danger of the church and Christmas being marginalised because of political correctness. The former Archdeacon of York, the Venerable George Austin, said: "I agree with him 150 per cent. I think that they are in a sense persecuting the church, but if that is so, they are shooting themselves in the foot, because the church always thrives when it is being persecuted."

  • Mike Laycock asked people in York if they agreed with the Archbishop that religion should not be taken out of Christmas.

Molly Popplewell said: "I believe Christ is in Christmas - after all, it means Christ's Mass. It's ridiculous that people are trying to take religion out of it."

John Van Dijk, 51, said: "I think Christmas is obviously about the Christian faith, and to water it down to appease other people is not right. You wouldn't water down Diwali."

Patricia Shepherd, 78, said: "I think that Christianity is under attack from the media. I feel that the Archbishop is correct and is a straight-talker."

Mary Wright, 84, said: "I think it should be religious. After all, if someone in the family has a birthday you would celebrate, and this is Christ's birthday we are celebrating."

Carol service at Minster

MORE than 2,000 people are expected to squeeze into York Minster tomorrow for one of the city's biggest church services of the year.

Archbishop of York, Dr John Sentamu will give the address at St Michael-le-Belfrey Church's annual carol service.

He will preach around the theme of "peace on earth", which organisers thought was particularly relevant given the conflicts in the Middle East.

Mark Rance, the church's head of operations, said the service would include a series of sketches by Riding Lights Theatre Company. An 80-strong choir will lead the congregation in traditional carols and a handful of more modern worship songs.

"It's our biggest service of the year and we put an enormous amount of effort into it," Mr Rance said.

"We are thrilled to have the Archbishop joining us."


Your Say YourYork Press

Malc, says...
7:27pm Sat 9 Dec 06

It is good to hear the Arhbishop giving a lead over the issue of Christ in Christmas. My Muslim friends (I am a Christian incidently) are amazed and upset by suggestions that Christians shouldn't enjoy one of their most important festivals. They are not offended by Christmas cards or carols, and in fact send cards out to their Christian friends as well as joining them in their partying. They are as offended by the PC brigade as I am and they enjoy my company at Eid.

Marjory, says...
9:19pm Sat 9 Dec 06

Who says it's illiberal atheists that're behind all this? Where is his evidence? It's tabloids like The Sun who're making this up just to stir up trouble. Urban myths about people trying to ban Christmas is just nonsense.
Also, Christmas was superimposed on already existing pagan mid-winter festivals. These festivals existed in just about all European cultures way before Christianity got here. Where do you think yule logs came from? Or Christmas trees? The Holly and the Ivy?

Fred, says...
12:53am Sun 10 Dec 06

I agree with the poster about right-wing myths. What really destroys the Christmas spirit is the secular party/booze cheap'n'cheerful atmosphere. It's either spiritual (religious if you are so inclined) or it's not at all. I am not particularly religious, but I find drinking as much as you can around Christmas simply repulsive. If only the archbishop would speak up against this - being drunk at Christmas is just not right.

rich plain, says...
11:19am Mon 11 Dec 06

Absolutely agree with you guys. It looks like Sentamu is playing at being the underdog here. He should try to take on the tabloid media who have made up this "PC brigade" myth so they too can claim to be defending something. But he won't - it's a lot easier to fight against an enemy who simply isn't there!

Annoyed, says...
12:23pm Mon 11 Dec 06

Liberal atheists, huh? What about the whining Muslims who seem to think that any expression of Christianity is offensive, even in this officially Christian country? Hmmm? Oh yeah, it wouldn't be PC to mention them.

marjory, says...
2:49pm Mon 11 Dec 06

It's not that it's not PC to mention such things as Muslims wanting to ban Christmas: it's because it's not true.

Even More Annoyed, says...
4:42pm Mon 11 Dec 06

D'you know I went looking for some anti-Christmas Muslims so I could give them a piece of my mind - only all those I talked to had nothing against Christmas and didn't want it banned at all. I was outraged! These people just aren't playing ball by being all sensible and refusing to give us something to moan about at Christmas. PC has gone mad, as indeed have I.

Comments are closed on this article.




Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »