News RSS Feed


Polo, the mint causing a hole in the ozone

12:22pm Thursday 6th March 2008

comment Comments (19)   Have your say »


THEY were invented in York, and are made just a mile from the city centre.

But one York retailer is selling Polo mints that have been shipped half-way round the world, in a move that has sparked condemnation from environmentalists.

Rather than selling home-produced Polos from the Nestlé Rowntree plant in Wigginton Road, Poundland, in Low Petergate, is instead stocking packets produced at the Nestlé factory in Indonesia - 7,300 miles from Yorkshire.

Andy D'Agorne, leader of the York Green Party, said the situation was "ridiculous" but increasingly common in today's food markets.

He said: "I dare say if you look at a lot of things sold in the £1 shops, they have been made in China or the other side of the globe, and shipped over here.

"But that's one of the things about carbon footprints that people are becoming more aware about."

There has been growing concern in recent years about food being flown unnecessarily long distances, leading to damaging carbon emissions. Fellow Green councillor Dave Taylor said Poundland and Nestlé should both share some of the blame in this case, but also said the Government should take a stand against wasteful firms clocking up air-miles on food.

He said: "We live in a world of global capitalism, and without some form of control the market just seeks the cheapest way of doing things, rather than taking issues like sustainability into account."

York Lib Dem councillor Christian Vassie said Poundland's behaviour typified needless international transportation of food.

He said: "It's completely ridiculous and mind-blowing that particular shop can sell packets of Polos cheaper having shipped them half-way round the world."

A Nestlé spokeswoman said: "It is beyond our control if they import stuff that was never designed for the UK. It's a grey market area.

"The Polos made in York are for the UK market. We would never bring Polos from Asia to sell in Poundland."

Nestlé is a member of the Food and Drink Federation, and has signed up to its five-step plan to tackle global warming, which includes a drive to reduce air-miles.

The spokeswoman said Nestlé staff would look into whether they had any power to control distribution of goods produced elsewhere in the world, but she added: "Provided they are acting legally, there is not much we can do."

A Poundland spokesperson said: "At Poundland we source products locally wherever possible.

"In some cases however, to enable us to provide consistent value to our customers, we also source products from across the world. Poundland has a very loyal customer base of savvy shoppers, who want to buy top name brands for less."



Your Say YourYork Press

Tonyone, says...
12:36pm Thu 6 Mar 08

Headline:
Polo, the mint causing a hole in the ozone

The hole in the ozone has closed up. It was all scaremongering. like 'acid rain'.

It is wrong to haul a product half way round the world though when it isn't necessary.


Monkey, Newcastle says...
12:49pm Thu 6 Mar 08

Good call Tony1- carbon has nothing to do with the ozone layer. Crappy journalism at its worst there...

wildthing666, york says...
12:52pm Thu 6 Mar 08

I have seen them in what used to be poundstrecher in clifton moor you get 8 or 10 tubes for £1 people don't realize that they may in fact be only the same number of polo's as the 6 packs sold in supermarkets (I haven't checked , not that sad )

Mike C, york says...
1:03pm Thu 6 Mar 08

Tonyone: the hole in the ozone layer is closing (mid-century if we're lucky) because humanity is phasing out the CFCs which caused it. And what's "scaremongering" about acid rain? It's real, it's prevalent, it affects crops and animals - including me. Some years ago I used to get rained on and it stung my eyes, luckily I've moved since.

LEAM DAVE, leamington spa says...
1:07pm Thu 6 Mar 08

As a student working for rowntrees, in the early eighties, we used to hand unload 40ft container loads of polos that were made in france then distributed from York.

slornie, Birmingham/York says...
1:11pm Thu 6 Mar 08

Even so, France is an awful lot closer than Indonesia.

ouserower, york says...
1:21pm Thu 6 Mar 08

As we only began measuring the ozone layer in the late 50's we have no idea if the hole is normal or not.

gypsy lee, my caravan says...
1:22pm Thu 6 Mar 08

bOring bOring bOring

John M, says...
1:42pm Thu 6 Mar 08

I once saw a large pile of three finger Kit Kats at a local car boot. I told the vendor that I had never seen them before and he told me they were intended for the Middle East. He said that both two fingers and four fingers were regarded as rude.

bobby dazzler, york says...
1:52pm Thu 6 Mar 08

Mike C wrote:
Tonyone: the hole in the ozone layer is closing (mid-century if we're lucky) because humanity is phasing out the CFCs which caused it. And what's "scaremongering" about acid rain? It's real, it's prevalent, it affects crops and animals - including me. Some years ago I used to get rained on and it stung my eyes, luckily I've moved since.
Ha getting water in your eye is going to sting!

Galloway Out, says...
1:57pm Thu 6 Mar 08

It just shows how much we are getting ripped off here, if it is cheaper to fly a product in from Indonesia than it is to buy it from 2 miles away.

tricky ricky, malton says...
2:03pm Thu 6 Mar 08

theres a hole where? you're just making that up surely

Sambo, York says...
2:48pm Thu 6 Mar 08

The pound shop also sells Nescafe Coffee which has been imported from over seas....It doesn't taste anything like the same - though same packaging etc...

AdmiralN, York Centre says...
3:31pm Thu 6 Mar 08

Mike C wrote:
Tonyone: the hole in the ozone layer is closing (mid-century if we're lucky) because humanity is phasing out the CFCs which caused it. And what's "scaremongering" about acid rain? It's real, it's prevalent, it affects crops and animals - including me. Some years ago I used to get rained on and it stung my eyes, luckily I've moved since.
Simple solution to this, Dont look up at the sky when it rains.

markymark, york says...
3:45pm Thu 6 Mar 08

A Nestlé spokeswoman said: "It is beyond our control if they import stuff that was never designed for the UK. It's a grey market area


Did she relly refer to polos' as "stuff" ???

Yesterdays spokesman referred to the dark kitkat chocolate as "the finest cocoa beans used to produce an intensely rich bittersweet dark chocolate"

He definitely gets my vote for the "big up the product award"
!!

addison, spain says...
4:56pm Thu 6 Mar 08

The polo plant in york will be closing soon because of all the imports from other countres cheap and willing to work

Mullarkian, York says...
6:08pm Thu 6 Mar 08

This is the first time I've the hole in the ozone mentioned for years, it's gone the way of all scientific sponsored scares like acid rain and just as the carbon footprint b0ll0x will.

never right, york says...
6:41pm Thu 6 Mar 08

you should ask them where they are getting the milk buttons from its not york or even nestle?????

John M, says...
7:41am Fri 7 Mar 08

There is another serious implication in this matter. The production line in Indonesia could be set up in such a way that cross-contamination with products containing zero tolerance substances such as peanuts and gluten is possible.

Comments are closed on this article.




Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »