News RSS Feed


Patient launched email campaign

7:57pm Wednesday 25th June 2008

comment Comments (8)   Have your say »


A PATIENT of York Hospital is launching an email campaign after waiting for a diagnosis for nine months.

As reported in The Press, Terry Donohue is in constant pain and must use a wheelchair if he is to move more than 50 metres.

He was struck down with the mystery illness, which began with stiffness in his knees, about nine months ago.

He said he saw one consultant who could not make a diagnosis, but was then put on another three-month waiting list to see another consultant who was also unable to make a diagnosis.

The same thing happened again and he eventually went private and was diagnosed as having haemochromatosis. It causes excess iron in the blood to be deposited in the organs and joints of the body and can be fatal if left untreated.

Mr Donohue, 56, of Eyre Close, Brayton, said he was contacted by York Hospital who said it was unsure about the diagnosis and believed it may actually stem from a neurological disorder.

After waiting nine months, Mr Donohue said he and his wife were now desperate and were urging people to contact the hospital's chief executive to ask for his help.

Mr Donhue said: "Living every day without a diagnosis is a living hell. It drives you to despair. I can't work, my business is failing and at the back of your mind is the reality of your house being re-possessed. Material things are nice, but that is not the real heartache.

"I see my family distraught, my wife suddenly and for no logical reason bursting into tears, day or night, unable to perform daily tasks due to the mental stress and the nervous breakdown this has caused her to have.

"I am unable to look after her and this alone causes me distress. All together this is a decline to total despair. I am housebound in torment not knowing what is wrong. A normal life is just a memory for us both.

"We want York Hospital to admit me or send me to a specialist centre to find a diagnosis and offer treatment, instead of putting me on hidden' waiting lists."

He has also asked that York Hospital send him for a second opinion at another hospital.

Mike Proctor, deputy chief executive at York Hospital, said he was trying to arrange that second opinion.

Mr Proctor said: "Our medical director has recently been able to talk to Mr Donohue which we know he appreciated. Since then, we have received further correspondence from Mr Donohue where he requests a second opinion at a different hospital with a specialist neurology team.

"We will do what we can, in liaison with Mr Donohue's general practitioner, to see that this request is acted on as quickly as possible, although the speed of access to another team in another hospital is not within our control."


Your Say YourYork Press

TwelvestringTrev, York says...
9:51pm Wed 25 Jun 08

Maybe Mr Donohue should have his domestic gas appliances checked.
I know someone who suffered the self same symptoms and was misdiagnosed by a Neurological consultant at York District Hospital.
They told him he had a neurological dissorder and his condition turned out to be down to long term accumulative exposure to Carbon Monoxide due to a faulted unserviced backboiler.

TwelvestringTrev, York says...
9:57pm Wed 25 Jun 08

Maybe Mr Donohue should have his domestic gas appliances checked.
I know someone who suffered the self same symptoms and was misdiagnosed by a Neurological consultant at York District Hospital.
They told him he had a neurological dissorder and his condition turned out to be down to long term accumulative exposure to Carbon Monoxide due to a faulted unserviced backboiler.

my opinion, york says...
10:19pm Wed 25 Jun 08

hes got haemochromatosis ???? , I advice your freind to sue the local authority or whoever it was who failed in their job to service the boiler

redjanet, york says...
11:15pm Wed 25 Jun 08

Although I am very sympathetic to this gentlemans case, I am afraid that many, many people have to wait as long as he has for a diagnosis, many a lot longer. If indeed it is suspected to be a nuerological disorder even this can take months and years to confirm. Too many people are running to the press complaining about the NHS, posing for photographs with pathetic feel sorry for me faces. There are probably hundreds of people out there that are suffering far more than Mr Donohue. So why should he expect to have priority treatment.

David H, York says...
8:09am Thu 26 Jun 08

Many people believe medical science is now so advanced that doctors can diagnose anything and everything. Sadly, this simply isn't true. Some people have to live with conditions for years without ever knowing what has caused it.

Hel n Damnation, York says...
9:20am Thu 26 Jun 08

redjanet wrote:
Although I am very sympathetic to this gentlemans case, I am afraid that many, many people have to wait as long as he has for a diagnosis, many a lot longer. If indeed it is suspected to be a nuerological disorder even this can take months and years to confirm. Too many people are running to the press complaining about the NHS, posing for photographs with pathetic feel sorry for me faces. There are probably hundreds of people out there that are suffering far more than Mr Donohue. So why should he expect to have priority treatment.
I do agree with Redjanet in that there will be many people who have had to wait significantly longer than 9 months for diagnosis and treatment, particularly for potential neurological illness, and each one of those people will feel many if not all of the frustrations Mr Donohue and his family are going through.
Unfortunately, a 3 month wait is not that long, comparatively, medical science not having found definitive strategies for diagnosing many such disorders. Don’t get me wrong, I truly hope Mr Donohue is offered treatment as quickly as possible, but I hope, too, that this isn’t going to create a further list of people talking to the press and, potentially, queue-jumping for medical assistance at the cost of equally significant, but less vocal, cases.

marjory, york says...
9:29am Thu 26 Jun 08

Although this situation is far from ideal, it is getting better. In the mid 90s, waiting times of 18 months were often the norm.

Anne, Louth says...
2:25pm Thu 26 Jun 08

Yes, I agree there are too many sob stories in the Press. However, this case highlights a situation that has been going on in York for far too long. My mother was told by her GP that she needed to see a Consultant Neurologist, but there was a 60 week waiting list. She saw the Neurologist privately, he diagnosed terminal lung cancer within minutes, and she lived a further 6 weeks. It's time to review waiting lists.

Comments are closed on this article.




Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »